200 West 72 Street (SW corner at Broadway);
2071 - 2079 Broadway; 200-202 West 72 Street
The Colonial Club was built 1892 to house an social organization dedicated to
drinking and perpetuating the memory of Revolutionary days. The building was
designed by Henry Kilburn as what the
NY Times described as...
A sort of colonial palazzo, mixing rich renaissance forms with light
Adam-style detailing. With Bedford limestone on the ground floor and pale
yellow Roman brick and gray terra cotta above, the building was ''delicate and
clear,'' said an article in the Real Estate Record and Guide the year it
opened.
The much-modified, underused and crumbling building had been the target of
developers since the late 1980's real-estate boom, although the collapse of
that bubble extended its life for another 20 years until the mid 2000's boom
brought it down. Strangely, the site then sat dormant for a significant period
of time, possibly due to
damage to surrounding buildings incurred during demolition,
before becoming a residential building containing a Trader Joe's on the ground floor.