Jacobs' Criteria for Success

Analysis of Jacobs' observations about neighborhoods requires defining what is meant by "failed" or, conversely, successful. Jacobs never clearly articulates an objective definition for failure or success, although the numerous examples and anecdotes in the book describing different neighborhoods do give implications of her opinions. It is clear that she has a strong preference for diverse, low-rise, tightly-knit older neighborhoods like the one surrounding her apartment at 555 Hudson Street in the West Village. Indeed, Jacob's passion almost seems to be an attraction to the largely vanished New York City of the mid 19th century.

Jacobs also had an unambiguous distaste for the large-scale development of her time, which had as their inspiration Le Corbusier's Radiant City (1920s), Ebeneezer Howard's Garden City (1898) and Daniel Burnham's City Beautiful (1893). Her preferences are more qualitative than quantitative, praising the Boston's North End neighborhood (which many in her time considered to be a slum) as full of "buoyancy, friendliness and good health" (Jacobs 1961, 13). Her repeated insults to neighborhoods she finds undesirable are the adjectives "dull" and "gray," or, expropriating a word from the urban renewers of her day, "The Great Blight of Dullness."

Jacobs' most direct (albeit ambiguous) definition of success in stated in her chapter on, "The Uses of City Neighborhoods":

A successful city neighborhood is a place that keeps sufficiently abreast of its problems so it is not destroyed by them. An unsuccessful neighborhood is a place that is overwhelmed by its defects and problems and is progressively more helpless before them. (Jacobs 1961, 146)

This conceptualization of success is clearly a reaction to the post-WWII decline of cities that she was observing in the 1950s. Jacobs elevates diversity as a primary virtue from which success flows, and she is explicit in spelling out the conditions that lead to diversity:

09/02/2009 11:26:04
Jacobs' block on Hudson Street viewed from the north
09/02/2009 11:28:58
Jacobs' block viewed from the south
09/02/2009 11:29:49
555 Hudson
09/02/2009 11:31:44
555 Hudson
08/07/2009 15:20:50
Rugged entryway on 551 Hudson
09/02/2009 11:26:52
Jane Jacobs Way
08/07/2009 15:15:33
Hudson Street north of Jacobs house
08/07/2009 15:25:56
Hudson Street south of Jacobs house
08/07/2009 15:36:20
Father Demo Square
09/02/2009 11:32:28
White Horse Tavern (1880) - Dylan Thomas' favorite bar
08/07/2009 15:09:01
Typical West Village side street

Next: What Jacobs Got Right and Wrong